Anchor Mom

Robyn Nance is a news anchor, mother, wife, daughter, sister, skier, community organizer, and champion for foster children in our community. In her blog she talks about her life, loves and a foible or two.

Beyond the Headlines

Melissa Luck has seen and covered many of the stories that affect residents of our community and in her blog she goes in-depth to talk more about those stories and how they impact our lives.

Kris' Forecast Focus

Chief Meteorologist Kris Crocker goes beyond temps and conditions to give you long-range forecasts, fun facts about our climate and answers to your weather questions.

The Night Shift

Delivering the nightly news is just a small part of Kalae Chock’s job; her blog gives the community a behind the scenes look at all of the madness that goes down on The Night Shift.

Point, Click, Learn

Colleen O’Brien serves as your guide to help you find intriguing, useful and sometimes just bizarre ‘Cool Clicks’ from all corners of the Internet. Where else would you find a Swiss granny to knit you socks?

Home » Beyond the Headlines, Top Blog

Born Behind Bars – What We Didn’t Say

 Melissa Luck
 February 16, 2011 9:30 am
 5 Comments
 

prisonI just finished up my special report called Born Behind Bars. It profiles a program in which Washington inmates are allowed to keep their babies while serving time in prison. Even though it was a 6 1/2 minute story (about 5 minutes longer than a typical news story), there are things I just didn’t have time to include. I hope if you have any questions or comments about the program, you’ll share them here or on the story on kxly.com. It’s our taxpayer money paying for these programs – the more we understand the better.

1. I’ve wanted to do this story for about 8 years. I heard about it shortly after I moved to Washington and couldn’t believe my ears; precious babies kept in prison? I was both fascinated a little horrified. Instead of making a snap judgment about the program, I decided to do some research and found that, while it’s still a scary place for anyone to be, these kids and their moms were actually doing well. It’s the best part of my job – being able to research things I find interesting and share them with you.

2. I’ve rarely seen a happier group of babies. The kids in that prison are surrounded by razor wire. They share acreage with some dangerous women who have done some very bad things. But, every single baby was smiling and happy the entire four hours we spent with them. We didn’t get to spend nearly enough time showing you the Early Head Start program and hearing from the women who staff it. What an incredible group – and, what they’re doing for these kids and their moms is amazing. They come to work and have to be searched to get in, then they have to walk through gates and metal detectors to get to their jobs. Most had never set foot inside a prison before they took this job. Several of them told me it’s the best job they’ve ever had. The kids are engaged, happy, smiling, using sign language, learning, etc. And, despite what these moms might tell you, there’s no way these kids would be getting that same treatment outside the prison. They see a doctor once a month, their moms get pre and post-natal care and they are loved by the people who work with them.

3. The Department of Corrections gave us no real restrictions on this story. We followed the usual guidelines for videotaping in prison, we had to be pre-screened and we had to be searched before we entered. The women who agreed to be on camera had to sign a release beforehand (the same thing happens when we do stories inside schools). Aside from that, DOC simply let us in, then stepped back. Some people may see what they feel is my positive spin on this story and assume DOC steered the direction of it. As a journalist, I would never allow that to happen. But, DOC didn’t try. They were in the midst of their own ordeal (we were there 2 days after Jayme Biendl’s funeral, the woman killed by an inmate at Monroe). This is a program they’re proud of, but they never tried to “spin it” – they simply told us what it is, warts and all. Fortunately for them, they aren’t too many warts on this one.

4. I believe the women can change. Of the four women we interviewed, I believe three of them when they say they won’t end up back in prison. I won’t say which ones – and, not everyone made it into our story. I’ve interviewed a lot of inmates and most of them refuse to take responsibility for what they’ve done. These women, the ones I believe will succeed, didn’t hold anything back. They simply shared their life story and told us how they were going to change. Seeing how they’re children are thriving, they don’t want to mess that up when they get out. Could I be wrong? Yep. But, I choose to be optimistic that what they’re doing is making them better people.

5. It’s still prison. Contrary to what you might think, I didn’t walk out of there thinking, “Wow, awesome! These women are so lucky!” We saw the hard reality, too. When we were done, we got in our car, went out to lunch along the waterfront in Gig Harbor, then drove home to our kids. I put my son to bed, took a hot bath and went to my own room to sleep. I couldn’t help but think of the women we just left; they can’t come and go as they please, they wear the same prison-issued clothes every day and they sleep in the same room with their children every night. They have very few freedoms – and, they don’t see their other kids or the rest of their family except, if they’re lucky, on visiting day. Do they deserve to be there? You bet. They committed serious crimes and are in prison for a reason. But, I have to disagree with all the people posting on the story who say “how lucky, they get everything taken care of”. Anyone who’s ever been in prison – especially pregnant or with a child – will tell you there’s nothing fun about it. And, guess what: most of these women would be getting state benefits whether they were in the prison or not. We’re already paying for it, we might as well get our money’s worth.

I understand not everyone will share my opinion about the validity of this program. Most of you will say that these women deserve to be punished for what they did. I agree. But, the kids didn’t do a thing – they have nothing to be punished for. And, if being with mom is safer and better in the long run than being in foster care or bouncing from family member to family member, why not give that a try?

I welcome all your comments and questions, even if you want to call me a bleeding-heart liberal! Open dialogue is what makes the world go ’round.

Popularity: 1% [?]

5 Comments »

  • Fabulous story, I currently am in the process to begin helping the women/ mommies here at Purdy alongside my church Chapel Hill Presbyterian Church. Bringning a Sunday service to them once a month. This is a incredible opportuniy for them as well. CHPC also assists with the visits they provide at the prison once a month where some of the mommies are allowed to play and eat with their children.

    Again the mommies are the ones that did the crime, we need to care for the children and give them their right to have their mothers.

    I would love to share with you my experiences as I begin this process of assisting at Purdy. Please e-mail me if you are interested.

    blessings & giggles
    Jeanie

  • peter breen says:

    Melissa, Having worked with prison families for the past 16 years your article has so much merit that I would suggest you submit it to some national paper, magazine, etc. so the rest of the country will appreciate and understand what a program like this does for the beginning years of a child.
    During these most tenderest years of a child, the process of “bonding” with a parent will form the entire future for the child and their relationships with the world. Sure, maybe some of the moms will slip up later on upon release, but I am willing to bet that the longterm outcome for most of the moms and children will be a ringing success.
    You know, coiled wire does not mean much to an infant. It’s the warmth and love that counts from a mother’s touch.
    For those who look at it from the cost-savings perspective, it’s a win-win. As you mentioned the AID costs to mom and child on the outside are a heck of a lot cheaper than long term prison costs of both mom, and maybe the child , later in life.
    Again, congratulations ! You have done a lot for our children with the article.

  • Melissa Luck says:

    Thanks to both of you for taking the time to comment. The story is being picked up by a lot of regional publications and I definitely raising awareness about the program. It’s drawing some criticism, sure, but that’s the beauty of putting out a story like this; people who are paying for the programs get to see where their money is going.

  • [...] suggest reading about the back story on Luck’s blog as well. And I’d welcome your thoughts about this [...]

  • Lisa says:

    Thank you for this very interesting work you have done reporting on this.What a wonderful progressive program that actually offers something positive to rehabilitate inmates, and help babies
    have a chance at healthy development.

Leave a comment!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.